Thermalwrong wrote on 2024-11-30, 03:24:
Ohh, I had assumed that your laptop had spontaneously stopped working because of corrosion, but expansion memory can cause problems too. I should have recommended removing any memory expansion modules *first*. Looks like the 440CDT only has 16MB of RAM vs the 460CDT's 32MB? So it's more likely that a 440CDT or 230CX will have a memory expansion board.
I had bought the laptop the week before last. After I received it, I turned it on immediately, and it booted up just fine. Then I unscrewed the palm rest and saw that the BIOS battery had leaked. After cleaning it with vinegar and isopropanol, it wouldn't turn on anymore. So your assumption wasn't entirely wrong. Unfortunately, I didn't perform a thorough test before cleaning, so I don't know whether the issue I currently (again) have already existed before the cleaning or not.
Thermalwrong wrote on 2024-11-30, 03:24:
Regarding installing an IBM module in place of the original, I'm not sure that will work? Looking at the pins vs my pinout document (taken from 500CDT maintenance manual and verified on my 460CDT), CAS0/1 pins are on pins 12 and 13 which looks like it's the case on your original module, but won't be the case on a JEDEC standard EDO SO-DIMM which puts VCC onto the CAS0 line.
The pinout of a Toshiba 144-pin EDO memory module is not JEDEC / IBM standards compliant either because it predates it or just Toshiba being Toshiba. It's possible that was causing some of your problems... There are pins on a Toshiba module / pinout that connect to 5v while the JEDEC pinout hooks them to Ground. Any SODIMM you install in a Toshiba laptop should be carefully inspected for a Toshiba part code or some note saying it's for a Toshiba laptop, standards were a mess back in the EDO days.
Okay, I wouldn't have thought that 'Toshiba EDO' RAM differs so much from 'IBM EDO' RAM or that Toshiba EDO RAM is so messed up. Thanks for the info!
I wanted to install Windows 95 on the 440CDT today and realized that my problems aren't fully resolved yet. I have two floppy drives for the 440CDT, but neither of them works. Fortunately, one of the CD-ROM drives I have for the device does work. So I booted from a Windows 98SE CD, partitioned and formatted the hard drive, copied the Windows 95 setup files, and started the setup from the hard drive. Scandisk completes successfully, you briefly see the Windows 95 setup, and then this appears:
The attachment Fault_Extender.jpeg is no longer available
I’ve encountered this error before on another system (Acer Desktop, 200MHz/233MHz). Back then, replacing the CPU resolved the issue: Re: Can't install Win98SE: "fault in MS-DOS extender"
I’ve also read that replacing the RAM has worked for others: https://www.techguy.org/posts/3151992/ (3rd post in this thread)
I first downloaded MemTest86, booted from the live CD, and tested the RAM:
The attachment memtest.jpeg is no longer available
(The test is still running in this screenshot, but even after three full iterations, no problems were found.)
What really confuses me is that during boot, 48MB is displayed:
The attachment 48MB_total_memory.jpeg is no longer available
However, MemTest only tests 32MB (see above for the MemTest execution). And here’s the kicker: without a RAM module, the laptop won’t boot and hangs at "05h," even though it supposedly has 16MB of onboard RAM. I’m wondering if the RAM chips on the mainboard are damaged.
Unfortunately, I only have this picture, but it doesn’t look great:
The attachment on-board-ram.jpeg is no longer available
I’m wondering how I could have overlooked this.
In the next few days, I plan to disassemble the laptop again and clean those areas, hoping the chips haven’t suffered permanent damage.
Otherwise, I’m considering whether I could simply desolder the chips. I wouldn’t miss the 16MB onboard RAM, but I suspect the board might expect those chips to be present and refuse to function entirely if I remove them.
The board has "Toshiba TC51V16165CFTS-60" chips soldered on. Getting the exact replacements is tricky. I’ve found "Toshiba TC51V17405CST-60" chips and wonder if I could replace the "TC51V16165CFTS-60" with the "TC51V17405CST-60"? (I’ve already done RAM chip soldering before, so I have some experience. For example, I upgraded an AWE 64 Value from 512KB to 2MB successfully: https://www.reddit.com/r/vintagecomputing/com … bmod_on_a_abit/ – while writing this, I realized that the mod was introduced/created by you, Thermalwrong: Creative AWE64 CT4500 upgraded to 2MB of RAM. Thanks for that! It worked perfectly, though I was a bit nervous at times 😉 )
Is there any way to test the TC51V17405CST-60 chips? (Preferably without having to desolder them.)
(I also tested another 64MB RAM module from Toshiba, which was in the mail today. But with the 64MB-Module, I wasn't even able to start MemTest.)
Edit:
Okay, ChatGPT answered me the question, if I can replace the "TC51V16165CFTS-60" with the "TC51V17405CST-60":
TL;DR: No, I cannot / I shouldn't.
Based on the available information, the TC51V16165CFTS-60 and TC51V17405CST-60 are both EDO DRAM chips from Toshiba, but they ha […]
Show full quote
Based on the available information, the TC51V16165CFTS-60 and TC51V17405CST-60 are both EDO DRAM chips from Toshiba, but they have different organizations and capacities:
TC51V16165CFTS-60: Organized as 1,048,576 words × 16 bits (1M × 16), providing a total of 16 Mbits.
DATASHEET ARCHIVE
TC51V17405CST-60: Organized as 4,194,304 words × 4 bits (4M × 4), providing a total of 16 Mbits.
OCTOPART
While both chips offer the same total memory capacity (16 Mbits), their internal organizations differ significantly. The TC51V16165CFTS-60 has a 16-bit data width, whereas the TC51V17405CST-60 has a 4-bit data width. This difference affects how data is accessed and managed within the system.
[...]
Recommendation:
Given these differences, it is not advisable to replace the TC51V16165CFTS-60 with the TC51V17405CST-60. To ensure proper functionality and compatibility, it's best to source a direct replacement that matches the original chip's specifications, particularly in terms of data width and organization.
[...]
But maybe I can replace the "TC51V16165CFTS-60" with one of these:
Alliance Memory AS4LC1M16E5-60TC
- ISSI IS41LV16100A-60T
- Oki Semiconductor MSM5116165D-60
The Toshiba TC51V16165CFTS-60 is a 16 Mbit (1M x 16) EDO DRAM chip. Finding a widely available direct replacement can be challen […]
Show full quote
The Toshiba TC51V16165CFTS-60 is a 16 Mbit (1M x 16) EDO DRAM chip. Finding a widely available direct replacement can be challenging due to the obsolescence of such components. However, here are some potential substitutes:
Alliance Memory AS4LC1M16E5-60TC: This is a 1M x 16-bit EDO DRAM with a 60ns access time, similar to the Toshiba chip. It operates at 5V and features extended data-out mode.
DIGCHIP
Integrated Silicon Solution Inc. (ISSI) IS41LV16100A-60T: This 1M x 16-bit EDO DRAM offers a 60ns access time and operates at 3.3V. Ensure your system supports 3.3V DRAM before considering this option.
DIGCHIP
Oki Semiconductor MSM5116165D-60: Another 1M x 16-bit EDO DRAM with a 60ns access time, operating at 3.3V. Verify voltage compatibility with your system.
DIGCHIP
Important Considerations:
Voltage Compatibility: The original Toshiba chip operates at 5V. Some alternatives operate at 3.3V. Using a 3.3V chip in a 5V system can cause malfunction or damage. Ensure your system can accommodate the voltage requirements of the replacement chip.
Package Type and Pin Configuration: Confirm that the physical package (e.g., TSOP) and pinout of the replacement match the original to ensure proper fit and function.
Availability: These components are considered obsolete, and availability may be limited. Check with electronic component distributors or specialized suppliers for stock.
Before proceeding with any replacement, consult your system's documentation or a professional technician to ensure compatibility and prevent potential damage.