Reply 41760 of 56000, by bjwil1991
- Rank
- l33t
TrashPanda wrote on 2022-01-01, 13:31:Kahenraz wrote on 2022-01-01, 12:00:The major difference comes from the following revisions (excluding firmware versions): […]
The major difference comes from the following revisions (excluding firmware versions):
MT-32
SC-55
SC-55MK2
SC-88The MT-32 is pre-General Midi so games which support it will only sound correct on this model. All of the later Sound Canvas models (SC prefix) are General Midi compatible but have a unique sound. A common goal of those who collect vintage synthesizers is to try and pair the model that most closely matches original composer's intent. And because of the wildly different variations of sound generated by different synthesizers, some things can sound either off or just plain wrong.
The CM and ST models are special in that they have no front panel LCD or array of buttons. If I'm going to pull out a synthesizer for general use I prefer one of these simply because there is less of a light show in my face and it's easier to hook up.
The SC-55MK2 is in my opinion the black sheep of the lot and can be skipped. I think Roland compositions of the time sound best on the SC-55 and the SC-88 has a mode that emulates the MK2 anyways. The SC-88 itself also has a unique set of sounds that may sound better in some instances but comes down to personal taste.
I do prefer the sound of the Yamaha for certain games such as Duke Nukem 3D. It has a very distinctive electric guitar that I think has a bit more punch than any of the Roland models. It also supports XG which is used by some games such as Final Fantasy 7 to great effect.
So in my opinion, a short list of synthesizers worth owning is the MT-32, SC-55, and Yamaha MU50.
The MT-32 has a wonderful sound but, because it is not General Midi compatible, can be skipped entirely if you don't play any of the games which utilize it. This leaves just two synthesizers, the SC-55 and the MU-50, both of which I would recommend. But if you had to choose only one then it should be the SC-55.
Could you say have a DOS PC setup with all three and switch between them as required ? Im guessing the two Roland ones are essentially external boxes .. not idea about the Yammy.
I think Clint from LGR has a Midi stack, I might watch a few of his videos about it.
I use an A/V switch box (powered switch box) that I can switch between my Tandy 3-voice, Yamaha FB-01, Roland MT-32 (old), and Yamaha DB50XG (externally via the CHiLL board).
It usually depends on the scenario and LGR's videos are good to watch so you can set it up similar to his and it'll be a cool thing to do. Watched his videos a long time ago and if I had room in my room/home office/computer lab, I'd set up one similar to his as well.
Discord: https://discord.gg/U5dJw7x
Systems from the Compaq Portable 1 to Ryzen 9 5950X
Twitch: https://twitch.tv/retropcuser